Feedback from the public

ESR

2.1.1.3. A member of the High Council of Justice or the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine is unable to pass decisions when faced with a conflict of interest

Problem solving:

2.1.1. There is a social trend towards a declining level of trust in the justice system. The law does not define integrity as a qualification requirement for members of the High Council of Justice and the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine

Deadlines for all measures within ESR

01.01.2024 - 30.09.2024

Implementation of SACP measures within ESR

Total number of measures – 2

1 1

Implemented Not implemented

Implementation of SACP measures within the scope of the Problem by main main performers

National Agency on Corruption Prevention

50%

Summarized general information on Measures

№	Name of the measure	The main implementer	Co-implementors	Performance indicator	Monitoring results (latest)	Статус
1	2.1.1.3.1 Arranging an analytical study of the mechanism of prevention and resolution of conflicts of interest in the proceedings of the High Council of Justice and the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine, the problems inherent in this mechanism and proposals on how to address them, and the presentation of the analytical study (particularly regarding the possibility of reporting a potential conflict of interest or submitting a voluntary declaration of private interest)	National Agency on Corruption Prevention		The analytical study has been conducted and a report on its findings has been presented.	The measure was not implemented on time and in full	Implemented
2	2.1.1.3.2 Drafting and submitting to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine a draft law proposing to eliminate the existing problems inherent in the mechanism of prevention and regulation of the conflict of interest in the proceedings of the High Council of Justice and the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine, taking into account the findings of the analytical study indicated in subclause 2.1.1.3.1	National Agency on Corruption Prevention		The draft law has been submitted to the Parliament of Ukraine.	The measure has not been implemented	Not implemented

Indicators of achievement of ESR

Total number of indicators – 3

Indicators fully achieved – 0

Partially achieved indicators – 0

Indicators with a score of 0% – 3

Summarized general information about Achievement Indicators

№	Indicators	Weight (%)
№	Indicators	Weight (%)	1	A report on the findings of the analytical study of the mechanisms of prevention and resolution of conflicts of interest in the proceedings of the High Council of Justice and the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine has been published.	30%
2	A law has taken effect, which has resolved the problems inherent in the mechanisms of prevention and resolution of conflicts of interest in the proceedings of the High Council of Justice and the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine.	60%
3	at least 80 percent of justice experts evaluate: a) the implemented procedure for reporting conflicts of interest in the work of a member of the High Council of Justice and the procedure for resolving conflicts of interest as being completely or generally effective in ensuring the impartiality and unbiased nature of decisions of the High Council of Justice (5 percent); b) the implemented procedure for reporting conflicts of interest in the work of a member of the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine and the procedure for resolving conflicts of interest as being completely or generally effective in ensuring the impartiality and unbiased nature of decisions of the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine (5 percent).	10%

ESR