Expected strategic result 2.1.3.4. The grounds and mechanisms for discontinuing disciplinary proceedings have been improved, in particular, a mechanism for discontinuing the disciplinary case against a judge in case of their resignation after the initiation of the disciplinary case against them has been introduced

Information about ESR Feedback from the public
Progress in the implementation of measures as of 23.11.2024
measures, the implementation of which as of 30.09.2024
1
1
Not implemented
Measures implemented (fully and partially) - 0 ( 0%)
Display in tabular form

Measures — 1

2.1.3.4.1. Drafting and submitting to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine a draft law that:
1) prohibits dismissing a judge from their position following their retirement until disciplinary proceedings against this judge have been finalized;
2) defines the grounds for suspending the retirement and revoking the status of a judge if the retired judge has behaved in a way that is incompatible with the title of a judge;
3) establishes the procedure for examining the matter of suspending the retirement and revoking the status of a judge if the retired judge has behaved in a way that is incompatible with the title of a judge.

The main implementer: Ministry of Justice of Ukraine

Indicators — 2

Evaluation of achievement of ESR — indicator weight —
1
0 / 70%

A law has taken effect, which:
a) prohibits dismissing a judge from their position following their retirement until disciplinary proceedings against this judge have been finalized (20 percent);
b) defines the grounds for suspending the retirement and revoking the status of a judge if the retired judge has behaved in a way that is incompatible with the title of a judge (30 percent);
c) establishes the procedure for examining the matter of suspending the retirement and revoking the status of a judge if the retired judge has behaved in a way that is incompatible with the title of a judge (20 percent).

2
0 / 30%

at least 80 percent of justice experts estimate that:
a) judge are not dismissed from their positions following their retirement until all disciplinary proceedings against this judge have been finalized (10 percent);
b) the grounds for suspending the retirement and revoking the status of a judge if the retired judge has behaved in a way that is incompatible with the title of a judge are clearly defined and predictable (10 percent);
c) the procedure for examining the matter of suspending the retirement and revoking the status of a judge if the retired judge has behaved in a way that is incompatible with the title of a judge ensures the unbiased and impartial examination of this matter (10 percent).

* - certain measures are common to several ESRs, but have a separate number (id)