Feedback from the public

ESR

2.7.1.6. Clear rules and procedures have been established for identifying and resolving conflicts of interest of members of working and expert groups (primarily those that support the procurement of medical products at the expense of the state budget and determine the lists of products to be procured), and their strict observance in practice is ensured

Problem solving:

2.7.1. Patients and doctors do not receive medications and medical devices in a timely manner and in full, in particular due to the incomplete transition to the new system of organization and control of medical procurement, and the incomplete regulation of the processes of identifying the needs for and accounting of medications

Deadlines for all measures within ESR

01.03.2023 - 31.12.2023

Implementation of SACP measures within ESR

Total number of measures – 5
3 1 1
Implemented Partially implemented Not implemented

Implementation of SACP measures within the scope of the Problem by main main performers

Ministry of Health of Ukraine

80%
5

Summarized general information on Measures

Name of the measure The main implementer Co-implementors Performance indicator Monitoring results (latest) Статус
1 2.7.1.6.1 Arranging an analytical study of the cases of conflict of interest involving members of consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies at the Ministry of Health (including those supporting the procurement of medical products at the expense of the state budget and determine the list of products to be procured), which will include proposals on ways to improve the current legislation pertaining to these issues Ministry of Health of Ukraine Національне агентство з питань запобігання корупції The analytical report has been prepared and made public.
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented
2 2.7.1.6.2 Holding a presentation of the report on the findings of the analytical study indicated in subclause 2.7.1.6.1, followed by its expert discussion Ministry of Health of Ukraine Національне агентство з питань запобігання корупції The conclusions and recommendations outlined in the analytical report have been discussed with the participation of representatives of government agencies, NGOs, international organizations, international technical assistance projects, and the academic community.
The measure was implemented on time, but partially
Partially implemented
3 2.7.1.6.3 Drafting and submitting to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine the draft law that incorporates the findings of the analytical report indicated in subclause 2.7.1.6.1, which:
1) makes improvements to normative legal regulation of instances of discovery and resolution of conflicts of interest involving members of consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies at the Ministry of Health (including those supporting the procurement of medical products at the expense of the state budget and determine the list of products to be procured);
2) provides for the grounds and procedure for holding individuals liable under law for violating the requirements with respect to the prevention and resolution of conflicts of interest;
3) provides for the procedure for reviewing reports by individuals or legal entities about signs of conflicts of interest involving members of consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies.
Ministry of Health of Ukraine Національне агентство з питань запобігання корупції The draft law has been submitted to the Parliament of Ukraine.
The measure has not been implemented
Not implemented
4 2.7.1.6.4 Creating a section on the official website of the Ministry of Health with complete information about consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies that have been formed and are operating at the Ministry, with a focus on the following aspects:
1) individual members of such bodies and their positions;
2) the agenda of meetings attended by them;
3) the decisions made.
Ministry of Health of Ukraine The relevant information has been published on the official website of the Ministry of Health.
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented
5 2.7.1.6.5 Creating a channel for reporting conflicts of interest involving members of the consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies at the Ministry of Health by the public and business community Ministry of Health of Ukraine The channel for reports is functioning.
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented

Indicators of achievement of ESR

Total number of indicators – 4

Indicators fully achieved – 0

Partially achieved indicators – 0

Indicators with a score of 0% – 4

Summarized general information about Achievement Indicators

Indicators Weight (%)
1 A report has been published on the findings of the analytical study of the cases of conflict of interest involving members of consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies at the Ministry of Health (including those supporting the procurement of medical products at the expense of the state budget and determine the list of products to be procured), which will include proposals on ways to improve the current legislation pertaining to these issues. 10%
2 A law has taken effect, which (taking into account the findings of the analytical study indicated in subclause 1 of clause 2.7.1.6):
a) makes improvements to normative legal regulation of instances of discovery and resolution of conflicts of interest involving members of consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies at the Ministry of Health (particularly those supporting the procurement of medical products at the expense of the state budget and determine the list of products to be procured) (20 percent);
b) provides for the grounds and procedure for holding individuals liable under law for violating the requirements with respect to the prevention and resolution of conflicts of interest (20 percent);
c) provides for the procedure for reviewing reports by individuals or legal entities about signs of conflicts of interest involving members of consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies (10 percent).
50%
3 The official website of the Ministry of Health has launched a section with complete information about consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies that have been formed and are operating at the Ministry, containing information about:
a) individual members of such bodies and their positions (10 percent);
b) the agenda of meetings attended by them (5 percent);
c) the resolutions passed (5 percent).
20%
4 A channel for reporting conflicts of interest involving members of the consultative, auxiliary, and other advisory bodies at the Ministry of Health by the public and business community is functioning. 20%

Key sources of assessment:

Additional sources of information: