Feedback from the public

ESR

2.7.6.2. Public funds are allocated among institution of higher education and research institutions in a transparent and effective manner based on objective, pre-determined procedures and performance indicators

Problem solving:

2.7.6. Conflicts of interest are present in the sector of education and science during formulation and implementation of state policy

Deadlines for all measures within ESR

01.03.2023 - 31.12.2024

Implementation of SACP measures within ESR

Total number of measures – 5

1 1 3

Implemented Partially implemented Not implemented

Implementation of SACP measures within the scope of the Problem by main main performers

Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine

40%

Summarized general information on Measures

№	Name of the measure	The main implementer	Co-implementors	Performance indicator	Monitoring results (latest)	Статус
1	2.7.6.2.1 Drafting and submitting to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine a draft law proposing to amend the Budget Code of Ukraine, specifically by: 1) amending subclause “c” of Clause 7 of Part 1 of Article 87 of the Budget Code of Ukraine to the effect that expenditures out of the state budget include expenditures for the pursuit of higher education by individuals who earned the right to obtain a higher education at the expense of the state budget (including on the conditions of a government contract) on a competitive basis; the allocation of expenditures among institutions of higher education shall be carried out according to the formula developed by the Ministry of Education and Science and approved by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine; 2) amending Clause 46 of Section VI “Final and Transitional Provisions” of the Budget Code of Ukraine with respect to the list of parameters of the formula of allocation of state budget expenditures for higher education among institutions of higher education; 3) providing for an exhaustive list of cases of allocation of expenditures out of the state budget and local budgets for the funding of academic and engineering research and projects without the use of competitive processes.	Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine	Міністерство фінансів України	The draft law has been submitted to the Parliament of Ukraine.	The measure has not been implemented	Not implemented
2	2.7.6.2.2 Drafting and submitting to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine a draft law proposing amendments to the Law of Ukraine On Higher Education, which stipulates that: 1) expenditures out of the state budget for higher education shall be allocated for institutions of higher education where the cost of educational services is established in keeping with the legislation on the indicative prime cost; 2) the amount of expenditures out of the state budget for higher education shall be allocated among institutions of higher education according to the formula developed by the Ministry of Education and Science and approved by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine.	Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine		The draft law has been submitted to the Parliament of Ukraine.	The measure was not implemented on time and in full	Implemented
3	2.7.6.2.3 Arranging an analytical study to update specific performance indicators used in the formula of allocation of the amount expenditures out of the state budget for higher education among institutions of higher education	Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine		The report on the findings of the analytical study has been published.	The measure has not been implemented	Not implemented
4	2.7.6.2.4 Holding a presentation of the report on the findings of the analytical study indicated in subclause 2.7.6.2.3, followed by its expert discussion	Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine		The expert discussion has been conducted and its results have been published.	The measure has not been implemented	Not implemented
5	2.7.6.2.5 Drafting and submitting to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine a draft resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on amendments to the Formula of allocation of expenditures out of the state budget for higher education among institutions of higher education, to the extent of updating the specific performance indicators used within the Formula, taking into account the findings of the analytical study indicated in subclause 2.7.6.2.3	Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine		The resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine has been adopted.	The measure was implemented on time, but partially	Partially implemented

Indicators of achievement of ESR

Total number of indicators – 4

Indicators fully achieved – 0

Partially achieved indicators – 1

Indicators with a score of 0% – 3

Оцінка досягнення ОСР - 17%

Рівень досягнення ОСР - низький

Summarized general information about Achievement Indicators

* - Вага - програмне значення індикатора в ОСР

№	Indicators	Weight* (%)	Assessment of achievement		Evaluation rationale	Data source/information manager
№	Indicators	Weight* (%)	for the year 2024	for the year 2025	Evaluation rationale	Data source/information manager
1	A law amending the Budget Code of Ukraine has taken effect, which: a) amended subclause “c” of Clause 7 of Part 1 of Article 87 of the said Code to the effect that expenditures out of the state budget include expenditures for the pursuit of higher education by individuals who earned the right to obtain a higher education at the expense of the state budget (including on the conditions of a government contract) on a competitive basis; their allocation among institutions of higher education is carried out using a formula developed by the central executive authority shaping and implementing public policy in the field of education and approved by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (10 percent); b) amended Clause 46 of Section VI “Final and Transitional Provisions” of said Code with respect to the list of indicators of the formula of allocation of state budget expenditures for higher education among institutions of higher education (5 percent); c) provides for an exhaustive list of cases of allocation of expenditures out of the state budget and local budgets for the funding of academic and engineering research and projects without the use of competitive processes (10 percent).	25%	0%		За результатами проведення І циклу поточної (щорічної) оцінки ефективності реалізації Антикорупційної стратегії на 2021-2025 роки та Державної антикорупційної програми на 2023-2025 роки встановлено, що індикатор № 1 очікуваного стратегічного результату 2.7.6.2 не досягнуто з огляду на те, що передбачений вказаним індикатором закон не набрав чинності. Відтак зазначеному індикатору присвоєно значенн... ->	Official printed publications Official website of the Parliament of Ukraine
2	The law on amendments to the Law of Ukraine On Higher Education has taken effect, which stipulates that: a) expenditures out of the state budget for higher education shall be allocated for institutions of higher education where the cost of educational services is established in keeping with the legislation on the indicative prime cost (10 percent); b) the amount of expenditures out of the state budget for higher education shall be allocated among institutions of higher education using a formula developed by the central executive authority shaping and implementing public policy in the field of education and approved by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine (10 percent).	20%	0%		За результатами проведення І циклу поточної (щорічної) оцінки ефективності реалізації Антикорупційної стратегії на 2021-2025 роки та Державної антикорупційної програми на 2023-2025 роки встановлено, що індикатор № 2 очікуваного стратегічного результату 2.7.6.2 не досягнуто з огляду на те, що передбачений вказаним індикатором закон не набрав чинності. Відтак зазначеному індикатору присвоєно значенн... ->	Official printed publications Official website of the Parliament of Ukraine
3	A report has been published on the findings of an analytical study to update specific performance indicators used in the formula of allocation of the amount expenditures out of the state budget for higher education among institutions of higher education.	20%	0%		За результатами проведення І циклу поточної (щорічної) оцінки ефективності реалізації Антикорупційної стратегії на 2021-2025 роки та Державної антикорупційної програми на 2023-2025 роки встановлено, що індикатор № 3 очікуваного стратегічного результату 2.7.6.2 не досягнуто з огляду на те, що аналітичне дослідження щодо уточнення конкретних показників результативності, які використовуються у формул... ->	Official website of the Ministry of Education and Science
4	A resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine has taken effect, amending the Formula of allocation of expenditures out of the state budget for higher education among institutions of higher education, to the extent of updating the specific performance indicators used within the Formula, taking into account the findings of the analytical study indicated in subclause 4 of clause 2.7.6.2.	35%	17%		За результатами проведення І циклу поточної (щорічної) оцінки ефективності реалізації Антикорупційної стратегії на 2021-2025 роки та Державної антикорупційної програми на 2023-2025 роки встановлено, що індикатор № 4 очікуваного стратегічного результату 2.7.6.2 досягнуто частково з огляду на те, що передбачена змістом вказаного індикатора постанова набрала чинності, однак зміни, що були внесені нею... ->	Official printed publications Official website of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine

Key sources of assessment:

1. Кабінет Міністрів України: ОСР 2.7.6.2 Індикатор 4. Постанова Кабінету Міністрів України від 15.03.2024 № 298 "Про внесення змін до постанови Кабінету Міністрів України від 24 грудня 2019 р. № 1146"

ESR