Feedback from the public

ESR

2.6.1.1. The electronic accounting system includes all the data obtained as a result of a full inventory of defense facilities, including data on defense land and land plots of defense industry entities

Problem solving:

2.6.1. Nontransparent and ineffective usage and disposition of defense land, immovable properties in the defense industry, as well as surplus movable property of the army, intellectual property; uncontrolled consumption of fuel procured for the needs of the Armed Forces

Deadlines for all measures within ESR

01.03.2023 - 31.12.2025

Implementation of SACP measures within ESR

Total number of measures – 23
5 2 4 12
Implemented Partially implemented In progress Not started

Implementation of SACP measures within the scope of the Problem by main main performers

Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine

33.3%
9

Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine

25%
4

Security Service of Ukraine

25%
4

National Guard of Ukraine

50%
2

Administration of the State Border Guard Service

50%
2

State Service of Ukraine for Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre

0%
2

Summarized general information on Measures

Name of the measure The main implementer Co-implementors Performance indicator Monitoring results (latest) Статус
1 2.6.1.1.3 Development of the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine order to military administration bodies directly subordinated to Ministry of defense of Ukraine, enterprises, establishments and organizations managed by such bodies, including business entities, whose corporate rights are controlled by the mentioned bodies, to perform inventory of real estate objects and land plots Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Order issued and published
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented
2 2.6.1.1.6 Performance of inventory of property rights for 100% real estate objects and land plots owned by enterprises, establishments and organizations, owned by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, including business entities, whose corporate rights are controlled by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, excluding ones located in the occupied territories and in territories adjacent to combat line Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Inventory performed, 100% real estate objects and lands registered, except those located in territories adjacent to combat line or temporarily occupied by Russian Federation
The measure was implemented on time, but partially
Partially implemented
3 2.6.1.1.7 Conducting the annual monitoring of the quantity of inventoried and registered real rights to immovable properties of the Ministry of Defense and enterprises, organizations, and institutions under the Ministry’s jurisdiction and land plots owned by enterprises, establishments and organizations, owned by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, including business entities, whose corporate rights are controlled by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, excluding ones located in the occupied territories and in territories adjacent to combat line Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Reports on the monitoring findings have been published.
There is progress in the implementation of the measure
In progress
4 2.6.1.1.8 Performance of inventory and registration of property rights in 100% of real estate objects and land plots of owned by enterprises, establishments and organizations, owned by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, including business entities, whose corporate rights are controlled by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, including ones that used to be occupied and in territories that were adjacent to combat line Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Completed inventory and registration of 100% of real estate objects and lands, including ones that used to be occupied and in territories that were adjacent to combat line Not started
5 2.6.1.1.9 Performance of annual monitoring on the number of inventoried and registered real estate and land plots property rights of enterprises, establishments and organizations, managed by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, including business entities, whose corporate rights are controlled by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, including ones that used to be occupied and in territories that were adjacent to combat line Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Published monitoring results report Not started
6 2.6.1.1.10 (1) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Inventory of 100% of lands, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation
The measure was implemented on time, but partially
Partially implemented
7 2.6.1.1.10 (2) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine Inventory of 100% of lands, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented
8 2.6.1.1.10 (3) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation Security Service of Ukraine Inventory of 100% of lands, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented
9 2.6.1.1.10 (4) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation National Guard of Ukraine Inventory of 100% of lands, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented
10 2.6.1.1.10 (5) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation Administration of the State Border Guard Service Inventory of 100% of lands, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation
The measure was implemented on time and in full
Implemented
11 2.6.1.1.11 (2) Annual monitoring of a number of inventoried and registered land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine Published report on monitoring results
There is progress in the implementation of the measure
In progress
12 2.6.1.1.11 (3) Annual monitoring of a number of inventoried and registered land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation Security Service of Ukraine Published report on monitoring results
There is progress in the implementation of the measure
In progress
13 2.6.1.1.11 (1) Annual monitoring of a number of inventoried and registered land property rights, except ones adjacent ot the combat line or occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Published report on monitoring results
There is progress in the implementation of the measure
In progress
14 2.6.1.1.12 (1) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Inventory of 100% land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation performed Not started
15 2.6.1.1.12 (2) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine Inventory of 100% land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation performed Not started
16 2.6.1.1.12 (3) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation Security Service of Ukraine Inventory of 100% land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation performed
Implementation of the measure has not started
Not started
17 2.6.1.1.12 (4) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation National Guard of Ukraine Inventory of 100% land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation performed Not started
18 2.6.1.1.12 (5) Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, Security Service of Ukraine, National Guard, and State Border Service performance of inventory and registration of land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation Administration of the State Border Guard Service Inventory of 100% land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation performed Not started
19 2.6.1.1.13 (1) Annual monitoring of a number of inventoried and registered land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Defenсe of Ukraine Monitoring results report published Not started
20 2.6.1.1.13 (3) Annual monitoring of a number of inventoried and registered land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation Security Service of Ukraine Monitoring results report published
Implementation of the measure has not started
Not started
21 2.6.1.1.13 (2) Annual monitoring of a number of inventoried and registered land property rights in territories that were adjacent to combat line or that were temporarily occupied by Russian Federation Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine Monitoring results report published Not started
22 2.6.1.1.14 Uploading Public cadaster map with data with data on land plots owned by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine and enterprises, establishments and organizations managed by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine, including business entities, whose corporate rights are managed by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine State Service of Ukraine for Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Міністерство оборони України, Служба безпеки України, Міністерство внутрішніх справ України Data on 100% of MoD lands was uploaded to the State land cadaster Not started
23 2.6.1.1.15 Publication of data on land plots owned by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine and enterprises, establishments and organizations, including business entities, whose corporate rights are managed by Ministry of Defense of Ukraine State Service of Ukraine for Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Data on lands published on public cadaster map Not started

Indicators of achievement of ESR

Total number of indicators – 4

Indicators fully achieved – 0

Partially achieved indicators – 0

Indicators with a score of 0% – 4

Summarized general information about Achievement Indicators

Indicators Weight (%)
1 за результатами проведення інвентаризації земель оборони:
а) здійснено реєстрацію речових прав щодо 100 відсотків земельних ділянок, що перебувають на балансі Міноборони, Національної гвардії, Держприкордонслужби та СБУ, а також інших користувачів земель оборони (30 відсотків);
б) відомості про 100 відсотків земель оборони з розподілом за користувачами земель включено до спеціального інформаційного шару про землі оборони в Публічній кадастровій карті (10 відсотків)
40%
2 набрав чинності наказ Міноборони, яким визначено завдання органам військового управління, безпосередньо підпорядкованим Міноборони, підприємствам, установам та організаціям, які належать до сфери управління таких органів, а також господарським товариствам, повноваження з управління корпоративними правами яких здійснюють такі органи, провести інвентаризацію нерухомого майна та земельних ділянок 20%
3 забезпечено проведення інвентаризації та внесення відомостей про 100 відсотків нерухомого майна та земельних ділянок підприємств, установ і організацій, що належать до сфери управління Міноборони, господарських товариств, повноваження з управління корпоративними правами яких здійснює Міноборони, до Державного реєстру речових прав на нерухоме майно та Державного земельного кадастру 20%
4 оприлюднено спеціальний інформаційний шар про землі оборони з розподілом за користувачами земель на Публічній кадастровій карті
20%

Key sources of assessment:

Additional sources of information: