Feedback from the public

Measure

2.2.5.4.1. Drafting and submitting to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine a draft law proposing to improve the mechanism of exemption from or mitigation of liability and stipulate that:
1) in order to be exempted from liability for concerted anticompetitive actions, the party involved in such actions must notify the Antimonopoly Committee sooner than the other parties involved in such actions about such concerted anticompetitive actions and submit an application seeking exemption from liability, which must be submitted before the issuance of the preliminary conclusions in this case;
2) the person who engaged in concerted anticompetitive actions and submitted the application seeking exemption from liability to the Antimonopoly Committee sooner than the other parties involved in such actions shall be fully exempted from liability for committee such concerted anticompetitive actions, if this person: has disclosed such concerted anticompetitive actions to the Antimonopoly Committee; has discontinued their involvement in the concerted anticompetitive actions no later than the date of submission of the application seeking exemption from liability, except where such involvement in the anticompetitive actions is needed in order to ensure the integrity of examination of the case; has cooperated with agencies of the Antimonopoly Committee; has presented the relevant evidence which the Antimonopoly Committee did not possess;
3) any party involved in concerted anticompetitive actions may file an application with the Antimonopoly Committee seeking mitigation of liability by presenting the relevant evidence of the commission of concerted anticompetitive actions, which is of material significance for the issuance of a decision in this case and which the Antimonopoly Committee did not possess, as long as this party has disclosed such concerted anticompetitive actions to the Antimonopoly Committee; has suspended their involvement in the concerted anticompetitive actions no later than the date of submission of the application seeking exemption from liability; has cooperated with agencies of the Antimonopoly Committee;
4) the grounds and procedure for exemption from liability or mitigation of liability shall be established by the Antimonopoly Committee;
5) the procedure for exemption from liability or mitigation of liability shall define the procedure for documenting the submission of applications seeking exemption from liability or mitigation of liability, and the requirements for the format of such applications;
6) the information that exposes concerted anticompetitive actions and is of material significance of the issuance of a decision in the case shall include, in particular, the details of the applicant; information about all known parties involved in the concerted anticompetitive actions; a detailed description of the purpose and nature of the concerted anticompetitive actions; information about the boundaries of the commodity market affected by them; the market share covered by them; a description of contacts and interactions among the parties involved in the concerted anticompetitive actions; information about evidence of the concerned anticompetitive conduct;
7) officials and officers of the Antimonopoly Committee are prohibited from disclosing information about the applicant and the information reported by them;
8) the Antimonopoly Committee shall examine cases involving exemption from liability or mitigation of liability as well as inform the applicants about the decision to apply (or deny the application) of the program of exemption from liability or mitigation of liability within the time frame established by the Antimonopoly Committee;
9) the persons exempted from liability shall not be subject to the requirements of the Law of Ukraine On Public Procurement pertaining to the prohibition from participating in the procurement process due to the commission of concerted anticompetitive actions, except for the persons who repeatedly engaged in concerted anticompetitive actions;
10) in case of mitigation of liability, the fine amount shall be reduced by the agency of the Antimonopoly Committee compared to the previously calculated fine amount depending on the sequence in which the other parties involved in concerted anticompetitive actions have divulged information that exposes the concerted anticompetitive actions and is of material significance for the issuance of decisions in the case (by up to 50 percent for the first person, by up to 30 percent for the second person, and by up to 20 percent for the other parties).

Measure status:

Implemented

Actual execution date:

29.12.2023

The measure is aimed at achieving ESR:

2.2.5.4. To encourage disclosure of cartels, the mechanism of exemption or mitigation of liability of cartel members who report the cartel to the Antimonopoly Committee and provide relevant evidence has been improved on the basis of best practices of the European Union

Problem solving:

2.2.5. Insufficient information about the activities of the Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine and the fact that it is vested with a number of discretionary powers complicate public control over its activities and cause a high level of corruption risks. There is no effective program to mitigate the liability of cartel members who have reported the cartel and provided evidence.

Deadlines:

01.06.2023 - 31.12.2023

Responsible implementors (authorities):

The main implementer: Antimonopoly Committee of Ukraine

Sources of funding:

state budget

Volumes of financing (thousand UAH):

within the established budget allocations for the relevant year

Performance indicator:

The draft law has been submitted to the Parliament of Ukraine.

In accordance with the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine No. 1194 On Amendments to the State Anti-Corruption Programme for 2023-2025 dated 18 October 2024, the content of the measure was amended.

Implementing status

Progress/Result of implementation:

На офіційному вебсайті Комітету 30.06.2023 було оприлюднено для громадського обговорення проект Закону України «Про внесення змін до деяких законів України щодо удосконалення механізму звільнення або пом’якшення відповідальності».

Проект Закону України «Про внесення змін до деяких законів України щодо удосконалення механізму звільнення або пом’якшення відповідальності» направлено на погодження заінтересованим ЦОВВ (Мінфін, Мінекономіки, Мінцифри, НАЗК) та Урядовому офісу координації європейської та євроатлантичної інтеграції.

02.08.2023 проведено робочу узгоджувальну нараду щодо обговорення зауважень Мінекономіки до зазначеного законопроекту, за результатами узгоджувальної наради проект закону був доопрацьований у Комітеті.

Водночас, Верховна Рада України прийняла Закон України від 09.08.2023 № 3295-IX «Про внесення змін до деяких законодавчих актів України щодо вдосконалення законодавства про захист економічної конкуренції та діяльності Антимонопольного комітету України» (далі – Закон № 3295-IX) яким, зокрема, врегульовується питання звільнення від відповідальності.

Комітет з метою реалізації, зокрема, норм, передбачених абзацом третім підпункту 8 пункту 4, абзацом четвертим підпункту 27 пункту 6 розділу І Закону № 3295-IX, а також виконання Плану організації підготовки проектів актів та виконання інших завдань, необхідних для забезпечення реалізації Закону № 3295-IX, згідно з дорученням Прем’єр-міністра України Д. Шмигаля від 30.09.2023 № 28773/2/1-23-23, розробив та прийняв такі розпорядження:

від 30.11.2023 № 18-рп «Про затвердження Порядку врегулювання у справах про антиконкурентні узгоджені дії та зловживання монопольним (домінуючим) становищем на ринку», зареєстроване у Міністерстві юстиції України 27.12.2023 за № 2260/41316;

від 30.11.2023 № 19-рп «Про затвердження Порядку звільнення від відповідальності за вчинення порушення законодавства про захист економічної конкуренції у вигляді антиконкурентних узгоджених дій», зареєстроване у Міністерстві юстиції України 02.01.2024 за № 2/41347.

Вищезазначені нормативно-правові акти врегульовують, зокрема, питання передбачені заходом 2.2.5.4.1 Програми.

Monitoring results (quarterly):

09.12.2024:
The measure was implemented on time and in full
04.11.2024:
The measure was implemented on time, but partially
12.08.2024:
The measure was implemented on time, but partially
30.04.2024:
The measure was implemented on time, but partially

Additional sources of information: